Lancaster’s Holiday Horror: The Murder of Christy Mirack

The True Crime Times
15 min readDec 23, 2019
Source: LancasterPA.com

If you’ve ever visited Lancaster, Pennsylvania, or if you’re familiar with the town, then you probably associate it with its sprawling farmland and quaint Amish community. Lancaster is, indeed, a beautiful place. I grew up there, though I was a suburbanite.

The school in Nickel Mines, Lancaster County, where a milk deliveryman shot several Amish girls in 2006. — Source: PennLive.com

It’s hard to imagine that anything bad could happen in an idyllic place so steeped in the Christian faith, but Lancaster is not immune to things like murder. After all, in 2006 a crazed gunman shot 10 Amish children in a one-room schoolhouse, killing 6. This is known as the West Nickel Mines School Shooting.

However, the first time I realized that Lancaster wasn’t as quaint and innocent as I thought was in December 1992. I was in middle school at the time. A few days before Christmas, a young, pretty, and popular elementary school teacher living on the opposite end of town was brutally raped and murdered in her condo before leaving for work. It threw sleepy little Lancaster into a state of shock and mourning.

For almost 26 years, the case remained unsolved. But thanks to DNA and modern genealogy science, the murderer was finally caught, and Lancastrians were as shocked by who…

--

--

The True Crime Times

My name is Julie Fidler. I’m a writer, author, wife, and animal lover. I shed light on unsolved mysteries and shocking crimes.